by M.K.
The four friends had heard countless rumours about an abandoned mansion hidden deep in Brooklyn. According to the stories, anyone who dared to enter the mysterious building never made it out alive. Some people claimed they could hear whispers coming from inside, while others insisted they had seen strange shadows moving behind the dusty windows. Despite the terrifying rumours, the four friends were determined to discover what was really happening inside the mansion.
After driving nearly five hundred miles from home, they finally arrived. The enormous building stood before them, surrounded by dead trees and overgrown bushes. Its windows were shattered, its walls were covered in cracks, and its front garden looked as though nobody had set foot in it for decades.
Taking a deep breath, one of the friends slowly pushed the enormous wooden door. To their surprise, it creaked open with a deafening groan. They stepped inside and found themselves in a dark, dusty hallway, illuminated only by a single flickering candle. The air was freezing, and the silence was so unsettling that they could hear their own heartbeats.
As they explored further, they discovered an enormous spiral staircase leading to the top floor. Curiosity got the better of them, and they began climbing the ancient wooden steps. Suddenly, one of them noticed something strange: there were muddy footprints on the stairs, but they were leading upwards, not downwards.
At the top of the staircase stood a rusted metal door. One of the friends slowly turned the handle, and it opened with a loud screech. Behind it was a gigantic room containing four dusty portraits. Each portrait showed one of the four friends. However, there was something deeply disturbing about them. The paintings showed exactly what they looked like, except they were much older, with grey hair, wrinkled faces and terrified expressions.
The friends stood frozen in disbelief. How could someone possibly have painted them before they had even arrived?
Suddenly, a strange whisper echoed through the room.
“You shouldn’t be here…”
They immediately turned around, but nobody was there.
Downstairs, the candle began glowing brighter and brighter until its light filled the entire hallway. Moments later, the temperature rose dramatically, and the friends struggled to remain standing. Then, one of the portraits began to move. Its painted eyes slowly turned towards them.
“Please… don’t leave us here,” a weak voice whispered.
The friends screamed and rushed towards the staircase. But before they could reach it, one of them noticed something terrifying. The portrait was no longer showing four elderly people.
It was showing only three.
Confused, they turned around. One of their friends had disappeared.
They desperately called his name, searching every corner of the room, but there was no sign of him. Then, they heard a familiar voice coming from the portrait.
“Guys? Help me!”
To their absolute horror, their missing friend was now trapped inside the painting, standing beside the other three elderly figures. His face was pale, and his eyes were filled with terror.
The remaining three friends ran down the staircase as fast as they could, burst through the front door and sprinted towards their car. They drove away without looking back, promising never to speak about what had happened.
But the strangest part was yet to come.
When they finally arrived home, one of them noticed an old photograph lying on the passenger seat. It showed the four friends standing outside the mansion, smiling.
Confused, he turned the photograph over. Written on the back, in faded red ink, were the words:
“One of you was never meant to leave.”
His blood ran cold. He slowly looked at the other two friends.
There were only three of them.
And then, from the back seat, a familiar voice whispered:
“You forgot me.”
The car radio switched on by itself. Through the static, they heard the same whisper from the mansion.
“You shouldn’t have left.”
Meanwhile, back in Brooklyn, a fifth portrait slowly appeared on the dusty wall.
And this time, it showed all four friends.
But none of them were smiling.